Manufacturing Site Selection Mapping Tool

The Five Points Manufacturing Site Selection Mapping Tool compares 362 US metropolitan areas across five cost dimensions critical to manufacturing operations: labor, industrial real estate, utility rates, state tax competitiveness, and economic development incentives. It is free to use and built for CFOs, operations leaders, and independent site selectors who need a rigorous, data-driven starting point before committing to a market.

Where should your next plant go? That is not a question that can be answered with a Google search or a shortlist based on gut feel. Labor cost alone varies by 40 to 60 percent across US markets. Industrial real estate rates in gateway cities can run three to four times the cost of equivalent space in secondary Midwest and Southeast markets. Add utility rates, state corporate tax structures, and the availability of discretionary economic development incentives, and the total cost-of-operations gap between the best and worst site locations often exceeds $5 million annually for a mid-sized manufacturing facility.

This tool gives you a defensible starting point. Use it to screen markets before you engage a broker, before you commission a formal study, and before you walk into an economic development meeting without knowing the competitive landscape.

The five cost dimensions

Every market in the tool is scored on the same five variables that drive the total cost of manufacturing operations. Understanding what each measures helps you weight them appropriately for your production model.

Manufacturing labor cost is typically the largest variable in the analysis. It accounts for 30 to 50 percent of total operating cost for most production environments. The tool draws on occupational wage data for production and materials handling occupations by metropolitan area, reflecting real differences in what companies pay for comparable labor across markets. Markets in the Southeast, Appalachian states, and Midwest industrial corridor consistently outperform coastal metros. Greenville-Spartanburg SC, Huntsville AL, Columbus OH, Indianapolis IN, and Louisville KY are among the markets that appear at the top of labor cost efficiency rankings across most industry types.

Industrial real estate cost covers lease rates for Class A and Class B industrial space, including distribution-adjacent and light manufacturing product. Coastal California, the Pacific Northwest, and major Northeastern markets have seen industrial rates climb sharply. By contrast, markets in central Tennessee, central Indiana, the Carolina Piedmont, and the Texas interior offer large available inventories at rates that have remained competitive. For capital-intensive projects that require significant square footage, the real estate variable alone can justify or eliminate a market.

Utility rates for manufacturing operations matter most to energy-intensive production: food and beverage processing, chemical manufacturing, advanced materials, aluminum smelting and fabrication, and any facility running three shifts. Industrial power rates vary by more than two times between the cheapest and most expensive states. The Tennessee Valley Authority service territory, the Pacific Northwest hydro corridor, and parts of the Great Plains offer rates that create structural cost advantages for high-consumption operations. The tool incorporates state-level industrial rate benchmarks indexed to reflect differences in rate structure and contract terms.

State tax competitiveness covers corporate income tax rates, sales tax on manufacturing inputs and equipment, personal income tax (a factor in executive relocation decisions), and property tax treatment of business personal property. Several states have eliminated corporate income tax entirely. Others impose combined marginal rates exceeding 10 percent. The treatment of manufacturing machinery and equipment for sales tax purposes is particularly material: states that exempt manufacturing inputs from sales tax create an immediate, recurring cost advantage that compounds with capital investment.

Economic development incentives represent discretionary funding that states and localities offer to attract capital investment and jobs. Cash grants, job training funds, infrastructure reimbursements, tax increment financing, and long-term property tax abatements can reduce net capital cost by 10 to 30 percent on qualifying projects. The availability and competitiveness of incentives varies significantly by state program structure, project size, county unemployment rate, and industry sector. Five Points negotiates these packages on behalf of clients and has recovered more than $200 million in incentives across completed projects.

How to use the tool

The default view shows estimated annual operating cost in dollars for each market, scaled to your project. You enter the number of jobs, facility square footage, and annual energy use, and the tool returns a projected annual operating cost built from labor, industrial real estate, and energy rates in that market. The resulting figure is built for a capital model, not just a ranking.

The map can also be viewed by labor pool, wages, real estate rates, utilities, or state tax competitiveness as individual layers. Industry presets for Automotive Heavy Mfg, Food & Beverage, Distribution & Logistics, Advanced Mfg Electronics, and Chemical Process adjust the weighting of inputs toward the cost structure of each sector. A Custom option lets you set your own weights.

Filter sliders let you narrow the map to markets meeting a maximum manufacturing wage or industrial real estate rate. Clicking any metro area opens a detail panel with a full cost breakdown: labor cost, real estate cost, energy cost, median manufacturing wage, industrial RE rate per square foot, electric rate, labor pool location quotient, estimated qualified worker population, and a state tax climate score. From that panel you can add the market to a side-by-side comparison or request a site report.

Who uses this tool

CFOs and VP-level operations leaders use the tool to build an early-stage market shortlist before engaging a site selection advisor or commercial real estate broker. Getting to three to five candidate markets with data before those conversations start improves the quality of the engagement and avoids paying broker fees to discover that a market does not pencil.

Independent site selectors use the tool as a rapid screening instrument for new client engagements, particularly when an initial client call surfaces requirements that point to a region before a full cost model is built.

Economic development professionals use the tool to understand where their market ranks relative to regional competitors and to prepare for competitive pitches. If your market scores in the bottom quartile on labor cost, knowing that before a site selector's visit lets you prepare a more targeted incentive package.

Corporate real estate teams at large manufacturers use the tool during annual portfolio reviews when evaluating footprint optimization, capacity additions, or consolidation of existing facilities into a new location.

About Five Points Strategic Advisors

Five Points Strategic Advisors is an Austin, Texas-based consulting firm specializing in manufacturing site selection, state and local incentives negotiation, and New Markets Tax Credit financing. Thane Hutcheson, the firm's president, has led site selection and incentives engagements for manufacturers across automotive supply chain, food and beverage processing, chemical manufacturing, distribution, and advanced manufacturing sectors.

Projects typically involve capital investments of $20 million to several hundred million dollars. The firm's work is advisory and transaction-oriented: we do not represent landlords or economic development agencies, which means our recommendations are driven entirely by client cost objectives and operational requirements.

If you are evaluating a new facility location, an expansion, or a footprint consolidation and want an independent analysis of your options, contact Five Points to discuss your project. Initial consultations are confidential and without obligation.

Contact Five Points to discuss your site selection project